CAFE BRIEF TO SUPPORT POLITICAL PRISONER BILL WHATCOTT

CANADIAN ASSOCIATION FOR FREE EXPRESSION  Inc., (CAFE)

P.O. Box 332,

Rexdale, ON., M9W 5L3

PH: 416-428-5308

Website: http://cafe.nfshost.com

William Gary Whatcott, 76739183

Northwest ICE Detention Centre

1623 East J Street

Tacoma, WA 98421

USA

November 21, 2026


For Presentation to Judge Rosen In Support of Mr. Whatcott’s Refugee Application & In  Opposition to Surrender – Extradition Request by Canada for William Gary Whatcott – A #076739183





The Government of Canada has made a request to extradite William Gary Whatcott A#076739183 now currently being held in the ICE Detention Centre in Tacoma, Washington. Mr. Whatcott is making a refugee claim as a person persecuted in the Dominion of Canada for the non-violent expression of his Christian religious belief.


The Canadian Association for Free Expression (CAFE) is a non-profit Canadian non-profit corporation incorporated by Letters Patent in the Province of Ontario. We have worked to maximize freedom of speech in Canada since 1983, Canada regrettably does not have a First Amendment. We have intervened in numerous legal cases on behalf of people punished for the non-violent exercise of their speech in religious or political matters.

We consider Mr. Whatcott both a political prisoner and a prisoner of conscience as defined by Amnesty International: ” Prisoners of conscience are those who have been jailed or had their freedom restricted because of their political or religious beliefs, ethnic origin, gender, race, language, economic status, sexual orientation, or other status.
People who have used or advocated violence, even in the defense of their beliefs, cannot be labeled prisoners of conscience.“


Among other issues, Mr. Whatcott faces double jeopardy in Canada. In 2018, he was charged under Canada’s notorious “hate law” Sec.. 319 of the Criminal Code for “willfully promoting hate” against a protected privileged group: in this case, the LGBTQ community. The issue at law was his circulating a pamphlet at the 2016 Toronto Gay Pride Parade which, on one side, provided medical facts about negative consequences of homosexual sex, and, on the other side, stated the traditional Christian teaching condeming homosexual sex and urging participants  to take a different course and save their health and their souls. In 2021, at his first “hate law” trial Mr. Whatcott was acquitted. The Province of Ontario appealed and a second trial was ordered and held in the Spring of  2026. On September 16, Mr. Whatcott was convicted in an Ontario Court by Madam Justice Anne Molloy.. Sentencing was set for December 3. Later on September 16, Mr. Whatcott crossed into the United States. The next day he filed a claim for refugee status.


I have known Mr. Whatcott for more than 15 years. He admits he led a dissolute youth and committed minor crimes and used and sold narcotics. He went through a complete conversion when he was 18, detailed in his book Born in a Graveyard. Since then he has been an active committed Christian. His “crime” for which he could face up to two years in prison involved the peaceful, non-violent expression of his religious views on the practice of homosexual sex. He, thus, fits Amnesty International’s definition of “prisoner of conscience” and “political prisoner,” Mr. Whatcott’s behaviour was non-violent. As he sees it in conversations with me, he was fulfilling the Gospel directive: “Go forth and teach ye all nations” the Gospel.


Full disclosure: CAFE intervened on Mr. Whatcott’s behalf in 2018 in a British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal Case Oger v Whatcott, a civil case also involving free speech and political pamphleteering during a provincial election.In the Oger case a man known as Ronan Oger claimed to be transgendered and adopted the name Morgane. During the 2017 British Columbia provincial election, Oger ran for the socialist New Democratic Party (NDP). Relying on his traditional religious beliefs, Mr. Whatcott circulated several thousand copies of a leaflet urging people not to vote for Oger, arguing that, if he couldn’t get his sex right, Oger would not have the judgement needed to get economics or other pressing issues correct. Oger filed a complaint before the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal. After a contentious tribunal hearing, Mr. Whatcott was deemed to have committted a discriminatory practice and was fined $55,000. As an intervenor, CAFE argued the importance of freedom of speech and the right to express one’s religious beliefs, especially in the public forum during an election. Another intervenor on Mr. Whatcott’s behalf was the Justice Centre for Constitutions Freedom. Their statement of reasons for intervening is attached.

In the 1990s, Mr. Whatcott went to jail over a dozen times for violating the “bubble zone” that was declared around abortion clinics. His mere presence, praying or carrying a protest sign, was deemed to infringe the law. Again, Mr. Whatcott suffered imprisonment for the non-violent expression of his Gospel beliefs.

Early this century, Mr. Whatcott who was an accredited nurse moved to the province of Saskatchewan. When it came to light that Mr. Whatcott opposed abortion on religious grounds, he was stripped of his nursing licence and the right to make a living in his chosen profession. The enterprising Mr. Whatcott then started a carpet cleaning business.

While in Saskatchewan, Mr. Whatcott distributed leaflets critical of homosexual behaviour and influence in the school system.The flyers were the subject of complaints to the Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission. The case was appealed all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada which in its judgement came down strongly for the curtailment of Mr. Whatcott’s freedom to spread his Gospel beliefs. (Saskatchewan (Human Rights Commission v Whatcott (2013). In its conclusion, the Court held:

  Conclusion

[206]                     Section 14(1)(b) is a reasonable limit on freedom of expression and freedom of religion, demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society. I would therefore answer the constitutional questions as presented in the January 5, 2011 order of the Chief Justice as follows:

1.               Does s. 14(1)(b) of The Saskatchewan Human Rights Code, S.S. 1979, c. S-24.1, infringe s. 2(a) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms?

Answer: Yes.

2.               If so, is the infringement a reasonable limit prescribed by law as can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society under s. 1 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms?

Answer: A prohibition of any representation that “ridicules, belittles or otherwise affronts the dignity of” any person or class of persons on the basis of a prohibited ground is not a reasonable limit on freedom of religion.  Those words are constitutionally invalid and are severed from the statutory provision in accordance with these reasons.  The remaining prohibition of any representation “that exposes or tends to expose to hatred” any person or class of persons on the basis of a prohibited ground is a reasonable limit and demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.

3.               Does s. 14(1)(b) of The Saskatchewan Human Rights Code, S.S. 1979, c. S-24.1, infringe s. 2(b) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms?

Answer: Yes.

4.               If so, is the infringement a reasonable limit prescribed by law as can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society under s. 1 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms?

Answer: A prohibition of any representation that “ridicules, belittles or otherwise affronts the dignity of” any person or class of persons on the basis of a prohibited ground is not a reasonable limit on freedom of expression. Those words are constitutionally invalid and are severed from the statutory provision in accordance with these reasons.  The remaining prohibition of any representation “that exposes or tends to expose to hatred” any person or class of persons on the basis of a prohibited ground is a reasonable limit and demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.

[207]                     I would therefore allow the appeal in part, and reinstate the Tribunal’s decision as to Flyers D and E.  I would dismiss the appeal with respect to Flyers F and G.  Given that Mr. Whatcott was found in contravention of the Code, the Commission is awarded costs throughout, including costs of the application for leave to appeal in this Court.


We hope that Mr. Whatcott will be granted political asylum as a person persecuted for his religious beliefs. The quest for religious liberty was what drew many of the original colonists to America’s shores. In this matter, we urge that you deny the extradition request of the Government of Canada.

To assist the Court, we attach several press reports on Mr. Whatcott.


This is our respectful submission.

Paul Fromm

Director

Activist Bill Whatcott found guilty of LGBT ‘hate’ on leaflets from 10 years ago


Bill Whatcott incorporated graphic images and language in his flyers but did so because he was engaged in a self-described ‘spiritual war’ to ‘strike against the dark forces’ of gay pride.

Featured Image nadtochiyShutterstock


LifeSiteNews
staff

  • 31

Fri Sep 18, 2026 – 3:15 pm EDT

Listen to this article

5 min

Updated on September 21, 2026

(LifeSiteNews) — Christian pro-family activist Bill Whatcott was found guilty of “hate” against gay men by a Canadian court over flyers that he distributed during a Toronto “pride” event a decade ago.

While the court’s ruling has not yet been published, according to a report by the Toronto Star, Superior Court Justice Anne Molloy rejected Whatcott’s explanation that he is motivated by his Christian faith to evangelize those who face “eternal peril” if they do not repent.

Molloy reportedly said that the flyers go beyond “distaste, dislike, or merely being offensive. It is intense and extreme. It is hatred.” 

“Looking at the whole picture, Mr. Whatcott, by his actions, has demonstrated a deep animus towards members of the gay community, notwithstanding his testimony that he wants only to save their souls by having them repent their sins. He is far from a simple Christian missionary seeking to convert sinners. He is an activist and an attention seeker. He loves the spectacle of what he did. He enjoyed the attention and he continues to do so,” wrote Judge Molloy, according to the Star. 

“Many of the things included in his flyer standing alone are merely offensive and would not amount to hate. However, the combined effect of the whole flyer, the length to which Mr. Whatcott went to deliver his ‘message,’ the range of people he gave it to and his gloating after the fact all support my ultimate finding that his intention in handing out the flyers at the parade was to vilify gay men. He knew that would be the effect of his actions” the judge said.

“Natural law is clear, homosexuality is incompatible with human nature. Disease, death and confusion are the sad and sordid realities of the homosexual lifestyle,” one of Whatcott’s flyers said. 

In another flyer, Whatcott urged recipients to call or email him “if you are tired of your sin and want to come to your Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ and receive the free gift of eternal life.” 

“It’s utterly remarkable how far ‘progressive’ authorities and fanatical LGBTQ activists in Canada have gone to persecute conservative Christian advocate Bill Whatcott. Ten years ago, Bill led a group of dressed-up ‘zombies’ into Toronto’s (perverse, nudity-filled) ‘gay pride’ parade and passed out gospel tracts masquerading as condom packages,” fellow activist Peter LaBarbera said on X of the judge’s ruling.   

“In a ‘retrial’ after previously being found innocent (hello, double jeopardy!), Ontario’s highest court found Bill guilty of ‘willfully promoting hatred’ against homosexuals,” LaBarbera continued. “I know Bill: he may be unorthodox, but does not hate people caught up in homosexuality. Rather, he desires to minister to them by sharing the life-changing Truth of Jesus Christ. That takes real guts in increasingly ‘woke totalitarian’ Canada.”

_____________________________

Skip to Main ContentAccessibility Help

MenuCBC GemCBC Listen

SearchSign In

Former Regina man guilty of promoting hate at Toronto Pride Parade | CBC News Loaded

Saskatchewan

Former Regina man guilty of promoting hate at Toronto Pride Parade

Judge says Bill Whatcott distributed 3,000 pamphlets full of ‘toxic imagery’ and hate

Colleen Silverthorn · CBC News · Posted: Sep 29, 2026 8:00 AM EDT | Last Updated: September 29

Text to Speech Icon

Listen to this article

Estimated 4 minutes

Bill Whatcott says he infiltrated Toronto’s Pride Parade 10 years ago to ‘strike against dark forces’ in the gay community (CBC)

Social Sharing

Anti-gay crusader Bill Whatcott has been found guilty of willfully promoting hatred during the 2016 Toronto Pride Parade.

The former Saskatchewan resident and his followers dressed up in green leotards and handed out graphic, homophobic pamphlets disguised as condoms.

Ontario Superior Court Justice Anne Molloy ruled earlier this month that Whatcott’s pamphlets were “thinly disguised scare mongering” full of “toxic imagery” designed to promote hate against the gay community.

“Looking at the whole picture, Mr. Whatcott, by his actions, has demonstrated a deep animus toward members of the gay community, notwithstanding his testimony that he wants only to save their souls by having them repent their sins,” Molloy stated in her Sept. 16, 2026, ruling.

“He is far from a simple Christian missionary seeking to convert sinners. He is an activist and an attention-seeker. He loves the spectacle of what he did, he enjoyed the attention, and he continues to do so.”

According to agreed-upon statements of fact in Ontario Superior Court of Justice documents, Whatcott and six of his followers had signed up to march in the 2016 Toronto Pride Parade under the name “Gay Zombies Cannabis Consumers Association.”

Whatcott, who admitted to using a false name to enter the parade, and his followers wore lime-green spandex body suits, masks and hoods to cover their faces.

Some wore rainbow coloured clothing, while Whatcott donned a tutu and super-hero cape to hand out roughly 3,000  pamphlets disguised to look like condoms.

Those pamphlets contained graphic pictures, including some of anal warts and another of a deceased man, who allegedly died of AIDS, along with text stating, “Disease, death and confusion are the sordid realities of the homosexual lifestyle.”

Whatcott told the court his group “infiltrated” the parade to “strike at the dark forces” of the gay community.

Toronto police received complaints about the pamphlets and charged Whatcott with distributing “anti-gay material which promoted hatred towards the gay community.”

Whatcott was acquitted on those charges during a 2021 trial, but the Court of Appeal ordered a retrial, deciding the original trial judge erred by not allowing evidence from an expert in the history of anti-gay discrimination.

Previous record of hate speech

Whatcott, a former nurse who left Saskatchewan and moved to Leduc, Alta., has a long history of distributing flyers and pamphlets targeting the gay community.

In 2013, the Supreme Court of Canada found him guilty of promoting hate after he put anti-gay flyers into people’s mailboxes in several Saskatchewan towns and cities.

The Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission had previously ruled against Whatcott for distributing the flyers in 2001 and 2002, saying the pamphlets used words like “filth,” “propaganda” and “sodomy” to describe gay relationships, violating the province’s human rights rules.

Whatcott says he’s a “conservative evangelical,” but admitted lying to Toronto Pride Parade organizers about his group and their identity. He said he thought the material in the pamphlets was toned down and avoided anything that might get him in trouble after his previous run-ins with the court.

Molloy disagreed, saying the flyers clearly promoted hatred against gay men and Whatcott knew exactly what he was doing.

“His statements went far beyond characterizing gay men as being in breach of God’s teachings about sexual mores. He knew that what he said would be considered hate speech, and he chose to spread it anyway.”

Expression of honestly-held beliefs during an election campaign censored

Published:

  • October 12, 2019

Share on:

Media inquiries: media@jccf.ca

Oger v. Whatcott

🔊 Listen to this case

~2 min read aloud

Home Expression of honestly-held beliefs during an election campaign censored

The Justice Centre intervened in the hearing of Oger v Whatcott (No. 16408) in the BC Human Rights Tribunal.

During the 2017 British Columbia provincial election campaign, activist Bill Whatcott handed out over 1,000 flyers in the electoral district of Vancouver False Creek. The flyer expressed Whatcott’s opinions and “concern about the promotion and growth of homosexuality and transvestitism in British Columbia.” In his flyers, Whatcott asserted that NDP candidate Morgane Oger was a male, and argued that “[t]hose who promote falsehoods like the NDP and BC’s major media . . . do so to their eternal peril.”

Oger narrowly lost the campaign to a former Vancouver mayor.

Oger filed a human rights complaint against Whatcott, alleging that Whatcott’s flyers had exposed Oger to discrimination, hatred and contempt under section 7 of the BC Human Rights Code.

In December of 2017, the Tribunal granted the Justice Centre permission to intervene in this case, to make submissions in defence of freedom of expression under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.  The Tribunal noted that the Justice Centre “may provide useful input … with regard to the law”.

At a five- day hearing before the Human Rights Tribunal, running December 11-14th and 17th, 2018, the Justice Centre provided oral and written submissions concerning the interpretation and application of the freedom of expression, guaranteed under section 2(b) of the Charter, in the Tribunal’s adjudication of the complaint and the complainant’s applications for costs.  In particular, the Justice Centre’s submissions focused on the critical importance of freedom of expression to the democratic discourse, especially during elections.

In this context, censoring expression of honest beliefs and views made during an election campaign runs directly contrary to the values underlying freedom of expression and the right to vote under section 3 of the Charter.

The purpose of election campaigns is to sift false allegations from true allegations, poor character from good character, and bad policies from good policies. To achieve this, citizens must not be prevented from expressing their beliefs and to criticize candidates openly and publicly. Likewise, if the Tribunal only to permits the electorate to hear censored opinions and approved beliefs, Canada’s democracy will become a sham.

The Tribunal released its decision on March 27, 2019, ruling that Mr. Whatcott had violated section 7 of the BC Human Rights Code and ordering that he pay $55,000 in damages

________________________________________

Expression of honestly-held beliefs during an election campaign censored

Published:

  • October 12, 2019

Share on:

Media inquiries: media@jccf.ca

Oger v. Whatcott

🔊 Listen to this case

~2 min read aloud

Home Expression of honestly-held beliefs during an election campaign censored

The Justice Centre intervened in the hearing of Oger v Whatcott (No. 16408) in the BC Human Rights Tribunal.

During the 2017 British Columbia provincial election campaign, activist Bill Whatcott handed out over 1,000 flyers in the electoral district of Vancouver False Creek. The flyer expressed Whatcott’s opinions and “concern about the promotion and growth of homosexuality and transvestitism in British Columbia.” In his flyers, Whatcott asserted that NDP candidate Morgane Oger was a male, and argued that “[t]hose who promote falsehoods like the NDP and BC’s major media . . . do so to their eternal peril.”

Oger narrowly lost the campaign to a former Vancouver mayor.

Oger filed a human rights complaint against Whatcott, alleging that Whatcott’s flyers had exposed Oger to discrimination, hatred and contempt under section 7 of the BC Human Rights Code.

In December of 2017, the Tribunal granted the Justice Centre permission to intervene in this case, to make submissions in defence of freedom of expression under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.  The Tribunal noted that the Justice Centre “may provide useful input … with regard to the law”.

At a five- day hearing before the Human Rights Tribunal, running December 11-14th and 17th, 2018, the Justice Centre provided oral and written submissions concerning the interpretation and application of the freedom of expression, guaranteed under section 2(b) of the Charter, in the Tribunal’s adjudication of the complaint and the complainant’s applications for costs.  In particular, the Justice Centre’s submissions focused on the critical importance of freedom of expression to the democratic discourse, especially during elections.

In this context, censoring expression of honest beliefs and views made during an election campaign runs directly contrary to the values underlying freedom of expression and the right to vote under section 3 of the Charter.

The purpose of election campaigns is to sift false allegations from true allegations, poor character from good character, and bad policies from good policies. To achieve this, citizens must not be prevented from expressing their beliefs and to criticize candidates openly and publicly. Likewise, if the Tribunal only to permits the electorate to hear censored opinions and approved beliefs, Canada’s democracy will become a sham.

The Tribunal released its decision on March 27, 2019, ruling that Mr. Whatcott had violated section 7 of the BC Human Rights Code and ordering that he pay $55,000 in damages.